Depreciation, compound decay, nominal and effective rates, and timelines with changing conditions.
Practise Finance, growth and decay in the app →
What gets asked
- Calculate straight-line and reducing-balance depreciation.
- Convert a nominal rate to an effective annual rate.
- Track an investment through a rate change or an extra deposit on a timeline.
- Decide which of two options is better, with reasons.
You must be able to
- Straight-line loses the same rand amount each year; reducing balance the same percentage.
- Divide a nominal rate by its compounding periods before compounding it back up.
- Move every amount on the timeline to one date before comparing or adding.
- Keep full calculator precision until the final rounding.
Traps that cost marks
- Growing a deposit made in year 3 for the full term. A cash flow only earns from the date it enters: count its periods from there.
- Comparing nominal rates with different compounding directly. Convert both to effective annual rates first — that is the common scale.
- Using for a car losing value. Decay uses : value shrinks by the rate each period.
Worked example
- .
- .
- .
Depreciation and decay
A new bakkie loses value from the day it leaves the showroom. Here are the two ways to count that loss.
- depreciation
- The loss in value of an item as it ages and is used. Bakkies and laptops depreciate.
- rate of depreciation
- The yearly percentage in a depreciation formula, written as the decimal . So gives .
- book value
- What the item is still worth after depreciation. It is in both formulas.
- straight-line method
- Depreciation that takes the same rand amount off every year: the rate times the price paid. It is also called simple decay.
- reducing-balance method
- Depreciation that takes the same percentage off every year, each time of the value at the start of that year. It is also called compound decay.
is the price paid, is the book value after years and is the rate of depreciation. The value goes down, so the plus in the growth formulas becomes a minus.
On the straight-line method the item loses every year, and that amount never changes. After years it has lost of those amounts. So .
On the reducing-balance method the item keeps of its value each year. At it keeps of its value at the start of that year. Multiply by that factor once for each year, so . The yearly loss shrinks as the value shrinks.
To work backwards, undo the formula. For the price paid, divide by , so every year is undone. For the rate, first find , the part kept each year. Over two years that takes a square root, over three a cube root. The rate is minus the part kept.
Where a paper prints an information sheet, both formulas are on it. Some print none, so know them by heart. Keep the full calculator value; round to the cent only at the end.
Rules to remember
- straight-line:
- reducing balance:
- price paid, reducing balance:
Examples
Worked answer
- , and .
- .
- Inside the bracket: , and .
- .
Answer: R
Every year took the same R75 600 off: of the price paid.
Worked answer
- Each year it keeps of its value.
- Substitute: .
- .
- .
Answer: R
Each year's came off a smaller value, so it lost less than on the straight line.
Worked answer
- Put the values into : .
- Divide both sides by : .
- Undo the square: . So , which is per year.
Answer: per year
is the part the bakkie keeps each year. The rate is the part it loses.
Traps
- Taking of the value left each year on the straight-line method. Straight-line takes the same amount every year: of the price paid.
- Writing four years at as one loss of on the reducing balance. Multiply by four times. Each year's comes off a smaller value.
- Using for a car losing value. Decay uses : value shrinks by the rate each period.
- Dividing R by once to find the price paid two years earlier. Two years of need two divisions: .
Nominal and effective rates
Two banks quote different rates. Here is how to tell which one really pays more in a year.
- compounding period
- How often interest is added to the account: monthly, quarterly, half-yearly or yearly.
- nominal rate
- The yearly rate a bank quotes, before compounding is taken into account. It is written , where is the number of compounding periods in a year.
- periodic rate
- The rate for one compounding period: the nominal rate divided by . At compounded monthly it is a month.
- effective rate
- The rate that, added once a year, gives the same growth as the compounding does. It is the true yearly rate.
A bank may say per year, compounded monthly. That does not mean you earn in a year. Each month the bank adds , and the next month's interest is worked out on the bigger amount. So the account grows by a little more than in the year.
The yearly growth factor is the monthly factor multiplied by itself twelve times. Subtract from that factor and you have the effective rate. The more often interest is added, the further the effective rate climbs above the nominal rate.
Two quoted rates with different compounding periods cannot be compared as they stand. They are on different scales. Change both to effective rates first, then compare them. Only then can you say which offer pays more, or which loan costs more.
Round only at the very end. Keep the periodic rate as a fraction or a full calculator value, and give the final rate as a percentage to two decimal places.
Rules to remember
Examples
Worked answer
- The periodic rate is per month.
- The yearly growth factor is
- Subtract : , which is per year.
Answer: per year
Monthly compounding lifted nominal to more than effective.
Worked answer
- Bank A: , so .
- Bank B: , so .
- Compare the effective rates: .
Answer: Bank B, by a very small margin
Bank A compounds more often, but Bank B's higher nominal rate still wins once both are on the same scale.
Worked answer
- The periodic rate is per month.
- The yearly growth factor is
- Subtract : , which is per year.
Answer: per year
The growth factor already counts the original amount, so comes off before writing the rate.
Traps
- Saying compounded monthly is in a year. Multiply the factor by itself twelve times, then subtract .
- Comparing quarterly with half-yearly directly. Convert both to effective annual rates first. That is the common scale.
- Deciding that the bank that compounds more often must pay more. Work out both effective rates. A higher nominal rate can beat more frequent compounding.
Learn and practise “Nominal and effective rates” in the app →
Timelines and choices
Deposits, withdrawals and a rate that changes: put it all on one line, then choose.
- timeline
- A line marked in years, with each amount and each change of rate written at its date.
- cash flow
- Any amount that moves in or out of an account: a deposit or a withdrawal.
- total cost
- Everything paid back on a loan: the amount borrowed, all the interest and every fee.
Draw a timeline first. Mark the years, with for today, and write each cash flow and change of rate at its date. Each move of money to a new date is a step that earns marks.
When the rate changes, split the timeline there. Grow the money to the change at the old rate. The new rate works on that whole balance, interest and all. A book value works the same way when the rate of depreciation changes.
With several cash flows, choose one date, usually the end. Grow each amount to that date, counting its periods from the date it enters. Only then add the deposits and subtract the withdrawals.
With monthly compounding, use the periodic rate and count months: two years is compounding periods.
To compare two loans, work out each total cost at the same date, fees included. Work compound interest as compound and simple interest as simple. Where a paper prints an information sheet, both formulas are on it. Some print none, so know them by heart.
Rules to remember
- simple growth:
- compound growth:
Examples
Worked answer
- Split the timeline at year , where the rate changes.
- At the change: .
- The new rate grows all of R46 656 for years: .
Answer: R
The grew the balance at the change, not the first R40 000.
Worked answer
- Periodic rate: . Move every amount to the end of year .
- R20 000 earns for all months:
- R8 000 earns only from the end of year : months,
- R5 000 leaves at the end of year , so move it months:
- Add the deposits, subtract the withdrawal:
Answer: R
Each amount earned only while it was in the account, and all were moved to one date.
Worked answer
- Option A, simple interest: .
- Option B, compound:
- Add Option A's fee: . Option B is cheaper, by
Answer: Option B, by R
Without the fee, Option A looks R608,15 cheaper: the wrong choice.
Traps
- Taking the new on the first R40 000. The new rate acts on the balance at the change: R46 656.
- Growing a deposit made in year 3 for the full term. A cash flow only earns from the date it enters: count its periods from there.
- Adding amounts that are valued at different dates. Move every amount to one date first. Only then add and subtract.
- Comparing the two loans without Option A's fee. The fee is part of the total cost. Leave it out and you pick the dearer loan.